Manifesto for the Reconstruction of Community Life, by Ruptura – 15 November 2026

Beyond traditional forms of organisation

Our central criticism is that the left is limiting its capacity for popular organising by insisting on traditional forms of mobilisation, without managing to reach a significant part of the population, that finds no place in existing structures.

This is not about abandoning the historical forms of workers’ organisation, but about recognising their limits and broadening our understanding of what it means to organise society politically. We need to ask not only how the left struggles, but whom it manages to organise, whom it is leaving out and, above all, what kind of social relations it is able to build.

1. The limits of traditional trade union organisation

We are not saying that unions are useless. We recognise their historical importance and their capacity to win concrete gains. However, we need to recognise a contradiction: in certain sectors, especially the most precarious, the human, material and political cost of organising can be enormous compared with very small gains.

Our experience with app-based workers is a case in point. Creating a union in a precarious sector, with dispersed workers, weak collective identification and difficulties in mobilising, can demand an immense amount of energy and resources to achieve rather limited results.

This does not mean giving up on these workers, but recognising that trade union organisation, on its own, cannot meet all the needs of popular organising.

2. The crisis of belonging and popular participation

People do not look only for political organisations. They look for spaces in which they can build meaningful social relationships, belong to a collective, identify with a project and see that collective effort pays off in concrete improvements to their lives.

There is a difference between an organisation that calls on people to take part in certain political activities and a community that is part of those people’s lives.

A neighbourhood association can organise a campaign for sanitation. But it can also organise cultural activities, spaces for children to play together, sports, community parties, mutual aid among residents and debates about the problems of the area.

These activities should not be understood merely as tools for drawing people into politics. They are part of building the community itself.

It is not enough to mobilise people around a demand. We need to build ties that make them want to stay together even when a particular demand no longer exists.

Political participation must stop being something episodic, tied to a demand or an election, and become part of people’s everyday experience.

3. The need to recover territorial, community and everyday organising

Organising by place of residence and territorial proximity can be a powerful path, but we need to go beyond housing demands.

It is not simply a matter of transferring trade union logic to the neighbourhoods, creating residents’ associations that function as a kind of territorial union.

We need to think of organisations capable of taking an active part in the everyday life of neighbourhoods, building relations of solidarity and creating permanent spaces of sociability.

This involves several dimensions:

Sociability: spaces for spending time together, leisure, culture and community activities that do not necessarily depend on consumption or alcohol.

Mutual aid: solidarity networks, help among residents, collective activities and responses to the community’s concrete needs.

Culture and education: cultural, sporting and educational activities and spaces for learning that bring different generations together.

Political participation: assemblies, debates, popular councils and collective organising around the problems and decisions that affect the area.

Community autonomy: the capacity to identify problems, devise solutions and carry out initiatives without depending permanently on parties, governments or outside institutions.

The struggle over sociability

We need to recognise a contradiction within the left itself: where are our spaces of sociability that are not essentially bars, alcohol-fuelled parties or settings confined to activists themselves?

If we intend to build broad popular organisations, we need to offer spaces in which families, children, older people, young people and people with different habits can spend time together.

We cannot expect people to build community ties around organisations that, in practice, offer few ways of being together beyond political activities or the traditional settings of activism.

Sociability is not a secondary detail of political organisation. It is part of the social infrastructure a community needs in order to exist.

The struggle over everyday life and the growth of the evangelical churches

One of the reasons many evangelical churches have managed to expand their presence in working-class neighbourhoods is their ability to become part of people’s everyday lives.

They do not offer only a religious doctrine. Many also offer:

Networks of welcome and belonging.

Relations of trust and mutual support.

Activities for families and children.

Spaces for spending time together and socialising.

Material and emotional support in difficult times.

A relatively permanent community, present at different moments of life.

We need to take this seriously.

It is not enough to criticise the political influence of the evangelical churches or to compete for their congregations at election time. We need to understand why these institutions manage to build such lasting ties with sections of the population.

In many areas, they have taken over spaces of sociability, care and organising that popular movements, parties and other institutions have ceased to occupy.

The point is not to reproduce the religious model, but to understand that popular organisation too must offer belonging, care and concrete community relations.

If the right manages to be present in people’s everyday lives while we turn up only at moments of political contest, we are competing on very unfavourable terms.

A critique of reliance on religious institutions

We also need to question the idea that the evangelical churches can simply be influenced or steered politically to the left.

There is a difference between engaging with evangelical people, respecting their religious freedom and recognising their social needs, and believing that religious institutions, as institutions, can easily be turned into instruments of a left-wing political project.

We need not assume that getting closer to religious leaders is necessarily a path to political transformation. Nor do we need to court religious institutions as if their support were a precondition for reaching the population.

This does not mean treating the evangelical churches as a homogeneous bloc or ignoring their internal contradictions. It means recognising that we need to build autonomous popular organisations, capable of offering belonging and participation independently of religious mediation.

We can also look critically at how certain religious currents and practices contribute to the cultural reproduction of individualist and meritocratic values compatible with the capitalist order.

Here we can draw on the analysis of the historical relationship between certain Protestant religious ideas and the formation of an ascetic work ethic favourable to capitalist development.

We need not reduce all evangelical churches to instruments for reproducing capitalism, but nor should we ignore the links between certain forms of religious expression and the reproduction of the values that sustain the existing social order.

4. The organisational vacuum and the struggle over who builds the community

A substantial part of the population finds no space in which to organise:

It does not belong to organised occupational groups.

It does not take part in student movements.

It is not necessarily linked to housing movements.

It finds no room for participation within the parties themselves.

Often, it also finds no spaces for spending time together, taking part and building something collectively outside institutions that already have their own structures of belonging.

The problem, then, is not only the absence of traditional political organisations. It is also the absence of spaces in which people can build ties, develop relations of trust, share experiences and organise their lives collectively.

This creates a contest that goes beyond institutional politics.

We are talking about who is able to build relations of trust, solidarity and belonging in our neighbourhoods.

We cannot depend exclusively on pre-existing organisational structures and wait for people to fit into them. We need to build new forms of organisation that start from the needs, relationships and concrete experiences of communities.

This requires abandoning an overly instrumental conception of popular organising: one in which the community is approached in order to support a demand, a candidacy or a political project defined in advance.

The community must be the subject of its own organisation, able to formulate its demands, set its priorities and decide the direction of its initiatives.

Here we find an important affinity with the case for libertarian municipalism.

Social transformation requires reclaiming politics as a public, territorial and directly participatory activity. We need to build institutions of direct democracy in which the population is not merely represented, but actually takes part in deliberating on collective affairs.

Territorial organising, in this sense, would not be merely a strategy for winning votes or extending the influence of a particular party. It would also be a process of building popular power and new forms of public life.

We also find an affinity with the understanding of community as the building of living relationships between people, based on reciprocity, encounter and shared responsibility.

Community should not be understood simply as a grouping of people with similar interests, but as a collective construction of relationships and experiences.

5. The need to rebuild community life as a horizon of social transformation

Our reflection is not limited to advocating a broadening of the left’s traditional forms of organisation. We are questioning the very way we understand the building of communities and popular participation.

We can identify three fundamental shifts:

From sectoral to territorial organising. Not organising only workers, students or residents around specific demands, but building spaces capable of bringing people together on the basis of their territorial proximity and their everyday experiences.

From political mobilisation to community building. Not turning up in neighbourhoods only to organise demonstrations, demands or election campaigns, but taking a permanent part in building spaces for spending time together, culture, solidarity, leisure and collective decision-making.

From the electoral contest to the contest over everyday life. Understanding that politics is also fought out in the way people build their ties, find belonging, share experiences and organise their lives. We need to become a concrete presence in the life of communities again.

This also leads us to recover an important historical experience: the PT’s [Workers’ Party’s] capacity to mobilise around municipal contests and the concrete problems of cities, especially before 2002.

The contests for city halls, popular participation and organising around urban issues showed a capacity for political building rooted in the neighbourhoods.

However, the progressive concentration of effort on the presidential contest contributed to the weakening of local work, in neighbourhoods and city halls.

We need to reflect on what was lost in this process and on how to recover a capacity for organising that does not depend exclusively on electoral cycles or on larger-scale institutional contests.

The horizon we are seeking is not simply to create more unions, associations or party branches. It is to build organisations that are socially relevant to people, that are part of their lives and that allow relations of trust, reciprocity and collective responsibility to develop.

We must not confuse building a community with building an electoral base or a base of activists.

If people have a place only as potential supporters of a party project, we go on reproducing an instrumental relationship with the population.

The transformation we imagine requires that the community have value in itself and the capacity to determine its own path. Political organisation should contribute to this, not appropriate the process.

6. Overcoming the political culture of defeat and recovering the capacity to win

We also need to question a feature of parts of the left: the tendency to cultivate a political culture excessively oriented towards defeat, resistance and the glorification of defeated projects and experiences.

The memory of historical struggles matters. We need to acknowledge the sacrifices, preserve the memory of the gains and learn from the defeats. However, there is a difference between preserving the memory of a struggle and turning defeat into a kind of political identity.

Resistance is necessary when our gains are under threat, when we face setbacks or when we need to preserve the conditions for continuing the struggle. But it cannot be our permanent horizon.

When resistance becomes the main element of political identity, we run the risk of naturalising a defensive position: we come to recognise ourselves more by what we fight against and what we have lost than by the society we intend to build.

We need to recover the capacity to formulate projects that are not limited to preventing setbacks, but are able to win concrete improvements, transform institutions and build new social relations.

We need to start talking about victories again, not just about resistance.

Victories have a material dimension, because they really improve people’s living conditions, but also a political and subjective one: they show that collective organisation works, strengthen confidence in common action, raise morale and encourage new forms of participation.

A community that wins concrete improvements, builds its own spaces for being together and becomes aware of its capacity to decide the direction of its neighbourhood develops the confidence to take on bigger challenges.

This also relates directly to our proposal for rebuilding community life. We cannot offer people only an identity of resistance in the face of a society they do not control. We need to show, through concrete experience, that collective organisation can produce alternatives, win space and improve their lives.

Our project must be able to produce experiences of transformation in the present that anticipate, if only partially, the social relations we want to build in the future.

Resistance should preserve our capacity to advance, not replace the prospect of advance.

In sum: what is our conclusion?

We are arguing for a broadening of the left’s forms of popular organisation, recovering the territorial, community and everyday dimension of politics.

But our proposal goes beyond simply diversifying the instruments of mobilisation.

We want to rebuild the collective capacity to create spaces for being together, relations of solidarity, institutions of participation and forms of community autonomy.

The point is not to replace unions with neighbourhood associations, to abandon the historical forms of organisation or to turn communities into instruments of party projects.

It is to recognise that the existing structures do not cover the whole of society and that we need to build new possibilities of organisation, belonging and participation.

Our criticism is that the left runs the risk of remaining confined to the organisations and social groups it already manages to mobilise, while leaving a huge part of the population unorganised.

The fundamental challenge then becomes: how do we build communities in which people not only organise to fight for rights, but also find the conditions to live, live together, take part and decide collectively the direction of their own community?

In the final analysis, we are asking not only how the left struggles, whom it manages to organise and whom it is leaving out, but also what kind of social relations it is able to build and what forms of collective life it can offer as an alternative to the existing society.

Our horizon, then, is not merely a left that can mobilise more people, but a society in which people themselves develop the capacity for organisation, participation, solidarity and self-government.

We do not want only to organise people to demand improvements within the existing society. We want to develop, out of everyday life itself, the collective capacities needed to build new social relations and new forms of social organisation.

Ruptura is a Brazilian collective of libertarian socialists.

The Portuguese original of this manifesto first appeared on Ruptura. English translation by the Left Renewal Blog.

Views: 2

Except where noted otherwise, original writing and translations produced by the Left Renewal Blog Collective are published under a Creative Commons Attribution–NonCommercial–ShareAlike 4.0 licence. Republished and translated material remains subject to the licence and terms of its original publication.