From Mina’s Substack
A recent Guardian open letter addressed Iran’s political prisoners directly, linking their struggle to US immigration detention and Israeli prisons holding Palestinians. It made two demands: that the Islamic Republic end executions and free political prisoners, and that the US and Israel end their wars and sanctions against Iran. The letter prompted a wave of criticism for failing some test of proper anti-imperialist politics. I want to examine two responses, by Behrouz Ghamari-Tabrizi and Vijay Prashad, because each raises a broader question. The first response concerns anyone who writes about Iran from a position of expertise: what relationship does the writing create with the people whose struggles it claims to explain or represent? The second concerns sections of the Western left: how do we make sense of a politics committed to anti-imperialism that nonetheless reproduces, toward particular non-Western subjects, the same kind of political invisibility that anti-colonial politics has long opposed?
Mina Khanlarzadeh (Ph.D., Columbia University; B.Sc., Physics, Sharif University of Technology) is a historian whose interdisciplinary work engages global political thought, literary and translation studies, gender studies, and the history of science.
More content from this blog
- How the US Christian Right Built an Interfaith Coalition Against LGBTQ Rights in Africa, by Caleb Okereke – 3 June 2026
- Palestinians Out, Foreign Workers In: How Israel Is Remaking Its Labor Force, by Charlotte Ritz-Jack and Dana Mills – 6 May 2026
- Israel’s Opposition Is Plotting a Return to Power. But It Remains Its Own Worst Enemy, by Joshua Leifer – 15 September 2025
- You Can’t Pretend to Care About the Working Class While You Try to Justify Their Deaths, by radical dumpling – 1 June 2026
- Beyond Geopolitics: Why Russia’s War in Ukraine Is Really About Capitalism in Crisis. Interview with Ivan Bakalov – 21 June 2025